Megadeth Info Forum

Zacna inicjatywa

Może by na główną walnąć info o nadchodzącym rankingu?

_________________

Wszystko elegancko, tylko niech się przynajmniej większość określi, bo rozmowa się toczy między garstką osób.
Zdecydowanie. Myślę, że sam chyba zbyt wiele nie zmienię, dlatego to najlepsze wyjście.

Ludziska, prosimy zatem wyrażać opinie i startujemy. Nie ma co się czaić.

Myslę, że najlepszym wyrażeniem opinii będzie po prostu wrzucenie tutaj notek do "13" (ew. zmian do wcześniejszych) i tyle
Może się to jakoś potoczy

Ja liste mam juz gotową, ale jednak musze się jeszcze z nią przespac, żeby ją upublicznić proponuje wyznaczyć jakiś termin do którego należy składać porawki/listy.

Dobra, to ja zacznę. W pierwszej kolejności idą utwory, którym zmieniłem ocenę:

Killing Is My Business... And Business Is Good! - 7
Chosen Ones - 4
Looking Down The Cross - 7

In My Darkest Hour - 8
Liar – 3

Washington Is Next! - 7
Gears of War - 6

Disconnect - 3
Moto Psycho - 5
1000 Times Goodbye - 5
Promises - 9
Return To Hangar – 5

Insomnia - 5

Trust - 4
The Disintegrators - 4
I'll Get Even - 7
She-Wolf - 6
FFF - 9

Angry Again - 8

Crown Of Worms - 7
Duke Nukem Theme - 5
Never Say Die - 7

A Tout Le Monde - 6
Black Curtains - 5

Sweating Bullets - 9
This Was My Life - 9
Captive Honour – 8

Hangar 18 – 9

Dialectic Chaos - 7
1,320' - 3
The Hardest Part Of Letting Go... - 6

A teraz TH1RT3EN:

Sudden Death - 8
Public Enemy No. 1 - 6
Whose Life (Is It Anyways?) - 5
We The People - 2
Guns, Drugs & Money - 2
Never Dead - 4
New World Order - 5
Fast Lane - 8
Black Swan - 2
Wrecker - 5
Millennium Of The Blind - 1
Deadly Nightshade - 7
13 - 10

Dobra, to i ja dam dobry przykład

TH1RT3EN:

Sudden Death - 8
Public Enemy No. 1 - 6
Whose Life (Is It Anyways?) - 6
We The People - 7
Guns, Drugs & Money - 3
Never Dead - 8
New World Order - 10
Fast Lane - 9
Black Swan - 4
Wrecker - 6
Millennium Of The Blind - 4
Deadly Nightshade - 5
13 - 8

PS.
Nad ewentualnymi zmianami starych ocen później pomyślę..

KIMB:
Last Rites/Loved to Death - 10
Killing Is My Business...and Business Is Good! - 8
The Skull Beneath the Skin - 8
These Boots - 5
Rattlehead - 7
Looking Down the Cross - 9
Mechanix - 8

PS...BWB:
Wake Up Dead - 11
The Conjuring - 8
Peace Sells - 9
Devil's Island - 9
Good Mourning / Black Friday - 9
I Ain't Superstitious - 7
My Last Words - 9

SFSG..SW:
Into the Lungs of Hell - 8
Set the World Afire - 9
502 - 4
In My Darkest Hour - 10
Hook In Mouth - 9

RIP:
Holy Wars... The Punishment Due - 13
Take No Prisoners - 10
Five Magics - 8
Lucretia - 8
Dawn Patrol - 3

CTE:
Skin O' My Teeth - 7
Symphony Of Destruction - 9
Architecture Of Aggression - 8
Psychotron - 8
Captive Honour - 10

Youthanasia:
A Tout Le Monde - 9

HT:
99 Ways To Die - 9
Diadems - 6

CW:
Use The Man - 6

RISK:
Prince Of Darkness - 8
I'll Be There - 6
Seven - 5

TWNAH:
Burning Bridges - 2
Promises - 7
When - 7

TSFH:
Blackmail The Universe - 9
Die Dead Enough - 12
Truth Be Told - 8
Of Mice And Men - 3

UA:
Washington Is Next! - 7
Never Walk Alone... A Call To Arms - 6
Gears of War - 7
Play For Blood - 8
You're Dead - 6

Bonusy:
Coming Home - 6
Crown Of Worms - 7
One Thing - 6
Out On The Tiles - 7

ENDGAME:
Dialectic Chaos - 9
This Day We Fight! - 8
44 Minutes - 7
1,320' - 10
Bite The Hand - 7
The Hardest Part Of Letting Go... - 4
Head Crusher - 9
The Right To Go Insane - 8

TH1RT3EN:
Sudden Death - 8
Public Enemy No. 1 - 6
Whose Life (Is It Anyways?) - 8
We The People - 7
Guns, Drugs & Money - 7
Never Dead - 8
New World Order - 9
Fast Lane - 8
Black Swan - 8
Wrecker - 8
Millennium Of The Blind - 2
Deadly Nightshade - 7
13 - 6


Próbowałem za dużo nie kombinować..., no ale. Samo tak wyszło.

13

Sudden Death - 6
Public Enemy No. 1 - 6
Whose Life (Is It Anyways?) - 8
We The People - 8
Guns, Drugs & Money - 3
Never Dead - 8
New World Order - 9
Fast Lane - 7
Black Swan - 8
Wrecker - 5
Millennium Of The Blind - 4
Deadly Nightshade - 5
13 - 6

Oceny numerów ze starych płyt na pewno częściowo pozmieniam, bo jakoś jak teraz na nie patrzę, to...

_________________
www.believer.dbv.pl - moja strona o jednym z najlepszych bandów grających progresywny/techniczny thrash
www.crossroads-of-metal.blogspot.com

LUDZIE, a jak mam w najprostszy sposób znaleźć swoje oceny? nie zamierzam wertować wszystkiego a podejrzewam że jest jakiś sposób

W temacie z wynikami ściągnij sobie plik z rankingiem w excelu

Moje ocenki:

Killing Is My Business... and Business Is Good!

Last Rites / Loved To Death - 8
Killing Is My Business... -7
Skull Beneath The Skin - 7
These Boots - 6
Rattlehead - 9
Chosen Ones - 6
Looking Down The Cross - 7
Mechanix - 9

Peace Sells... but Who's Buying?

Wake Up Dead - 8
The Conjuring - 8
Peace Sells - 8
Devils Island - 8
Good Mourning / Black Friday - 13
Bad Omen - 9
I Ain't Superstitious - 4
My Last Words - 8

So Far, So Good... So What!

Into The Lungs Of Hell - 7
Set The World Afire - 7
Anarchy In The U.K. - 7
Mary Jane - 9
502 - 6
In My Darkest Hour - 10
Liar - 7
Hook In Mouth - 7

Rust in Peace

Holy Wars... The Punishment Due - 12
Hangar 18 - 9
Take No Prisoners - 8
Five Magics - 10
Poison Was The Cure - 7
Lucretia - 8
Tornado Of Souls - 9
Dawn Patrol - 8
Rust In Peace... Polaris - 7

Countdown to Extinction

Skin O' My Teeth - 7
Symphony Of Destruction - 8
Architecture Of Aggression - 6
Foreclosure Of A Dream - 5
Sweating Bullets - 7
This Was My Life - 8
Countdown To Extinction - 10
High Speed Dirt - 8
Psychotron - 6
Captive Honour - 6
Ashes In Your Mouth - 6

Youthanasia

Reckoning Day - 9
Train Of Consequences - 8
Addicted To Chaos - 9
A Tout Le Monde - 7
Elysian Fields - 7
The Killing Road - 7
Blood Of Heroes - 7
Family Tree - 7
Youthanasia - 7
I Thought I Knew It All - 7
Black Curtains - 6
Victory - 7

Cryptic Writings

Trust - 8
Almost Honest - 7
Use The Man - 6
Mastermind - 5
The Disintegrators - 5
I'll Get Even - 6
Sin - 3
A Secret Place - 7
Have Cool, Will Travel - 5
She-Wolf - 6
Vortex - 5
FFF - 5

Risk

Insomnia - 7
Prince Of Darkness - 5
Crush 'Em - 3
Breadline - 5
The Doctor Is Calling - 6
I'll Be There - 6
Wanderlust - 5
Ecstasy - 2
Seven - 3
Time: The Beginning - 1
Time: The End - 5

The World Needs a Hero

Disconnect - 6
The World Needs A Hero - 5
Moto Psycho - 5
1000 Times Goodbye - 5
Burning Bridges - 5
Promises - 7
Recipe For Hate... Warhorse - 6
Losing My Senses - 4
Dread And The Fugitive Mind - 7
Silent Scorn - 9
Return To Hangar -6
When - 7

The System Has Failed

Blackmail The Universe - 6
Die Dead Enough - 7
Kick The Chair - 7
The Scorpion - 5
Tears In A Vial - 4
Back In A Day - 6
Something That I'm Not - 7
Truth Be Told - 6
Of Mice And Men - 6
Shadow Of Deth - 9
My Kingdom - 2

United Abominations

Sleepwalker - 7
Washington Is Next! - 11
Never Walk Alone... A Call To Arms - 6
United Abominations - 7
Gears Of War - 9
Blessed Are The Dead - 6
Pray For Blood - 6
Amerikhastan - 5
You're Dead - 7
Burnt Ice - 7

Endgame

Dialectic Chaos - 8
This Day We Fight! - 8
44 Minutes - 10
1,320' - 8
Bite The Hand - 6
Bodies - 7
Endgame - 7
The Hardest Part Of Letting Go... - 7
Head Crusher - 6
How The Story Ends - 8
The Right To Go Insane - 9

TH1RT3EN

Sudden Death - 8
Public Enemy No. 1 - 6
Whose Life (Is It Anyways?) - 6
We the People - 7
Guns, Drugs & Money - 6
Never Dead - 10
New World Order - 7
Fast Lane - 8
Black Swan - 7
Wrecker - 7
Millennium of the Blind - 9
Deadly Nightshade - 8
13 - 10

Hidden Treasures

No More Mr. Nice Guy - 7
Breakpoint - 5
Go To Hell - 6
Angry Again - 8
99 Ways To Die - 7
Paranoid - 7
Diadems - 6
Problems - 5

non-album

Kill The King - 7
Duke Nukem Theme - 6
Crown Of Worms - 6
Coming Home -8
Never Say Die - 6
Out On The Tiles - 4
One Thing - 7
Strange Ways - 6

Do paru kawałków mam jeszcze mieszane uczucia ale chyba już nic nie zmienie.

No! I to się nazywa konkret
Uprasza się o więcej takich postów

Aktualizacja:

KIMB
Last Rites/Loved to death - 8
KIM - 7
The skull beneath the skin - 6
Rattlehead - 8
Looking down the cross - 9
Mechanix - 7

PS
Devil's Island - 6
My last words - 8

RIP
Tornado of souls - 8

CW
The Disintegrators - 7

TSHF
Tears in a vial - 5
Something i'm not - 7

UA
Washington is next! - 5

E
This Day We Fight! - 9
Bite The Hand - 6
Bodies - 9
The Right To Go Insane - 9

13
Sudden Death - 8
Public Enemy no.1 - 6
Whose Life - 6
We the People - 8
GD&M - 5
Never Dead - 9
New World Order - 9
Fast Lane - 8
Black Swan - 4
Wrecker - 8
Millennium - 8
Deadly Nightshide - 9
13 - 9

INNE
Crown of worms - 4

_________________

To i ja się dołączę. Na razie tylko do części albumów, resztę dołączę po głębszych przesłuchaniach- nie zdążyłem się jeszcze zapoznać

Killing Is My Business... and Business Is Good!

Last Rites / Loved To Death - 7
Killing Is My Business... -8
Skull Beneath The Skin - 8
These Boots - 6
Rattlehead - 10
Chosen Ones - 10
Looking Down The Cross - 10
Mechanix - 8

Peace Sells... but Who's Buying?

Wake Up Dead - 12
The Conjuring - 9
Peace Sells - 9
Devils Island - 10
Good Mourning / Black Friday - 10
Bad Omen - 8
I Ain't Superstitious - 4
My Last Words - 9

So Far, So Good... So What!

Into The Lungs Of Hell - 10
Set The World Afire - 10
Anarchy In The U.K. - 5
Mary Jane - 6
502 - 9
In My Darkest Hour - 10
Liar - 9
Hook In Mouth - 10

Rust in Peace

Holy Wars... The Punishment Due - 13
Hangar 18 - 9
Take No Prisoners - 9
Five Magics - 10
Poison Was The Cure - 8
Lucretia - 5
Tornado Of Souls - 10
Dawn Patrol - 8
Rust In Peace... Polaris - 9

Countdown to Extinction

Skin O' My Teeth - 6
Symphony Of Destruction - 8
Architecture Of Aggression - 7
Foreclosure Of A Dream - 6
Sweating Bullets - 10
This Was My Life - 10
Countdown To Extinction - 10
High Speed Dirt - 5
Psychotron - 3
Captive Honour - 3
Ashes In Your Mouth - 11

Youthanasia

Reckoning Day - 8
Train Of Consequences - 6
Addicted To Chaos - 9
A Tout Le Monde - 8
Elysian Fields - 5
The Killing Road - 8
Blood Of Heroes - 8
Family Tree - 8
Youthanasia - 10
I Thought I Knew It All - 9
Black Curtains - 9
Victory - 9

Cryptic Writings

Trust - 7
Almost Honest - 4
Use The Man - 7
Mastermind - 10
The Disintegrators - 10
I'll Get Even - 10
Sin - 9
A Secret Place - 8
Have Cool, Will Travel - 5
She-Wolf - 10
Vortex - 4
FFF - 10



The World Needs a Hero

Disconnect - 9
The World Needs A Hero - 7
Moto Psycho - 7
1000 Times Goodbye - 10
Burning Bridges - 8
Promises - 10
Recipe For Hate... Warhorse - 10
Losing My Senses - 7
Dread And The Fugitive Mind - 10
Silent Scorn - 9
Return To Hangar -10
When - 10

The System Has Failed

Blackmail The Universe - 10
Die Dead Enough - 7
Kick The Chair - 9
The Scorpion - 7
Tears In A Vial - 10
Back In A Day - 10
Something That I'm Not - 5
Truth Be Told - 10
Of Mice And Men - 3
Shadow Of Deth - 5
My Kingdom - 3

Endgame

Dialectic Chaos - 8
This Day We Fight! - 8
44 Minutes - 8
1,320' - 8
Bite The Hand - 2
Bodies - 8
Endgame - 10
The Hardest Part Of Letting Go... - 8
Head Crusher - 8
How The Story Ends - 8
The Right To Go Insane - 9

Teraz wyjeżdżam, więc resztę w przyszłym tygodniu dorzucę.

Ja też postaram się dzisiaj wystawić oceny

To i ja zacną idee wspomogę

Killing Is My Business... and Business Is Good!

Last Rites / Loved To Death - 8
Killing Is My Business... -9
Skull Beneath The Skin - 7
These Boots - 7
Rattlehead - 10
Chosen Ones - 7
Looking Down The Cross - 8
Mechanix - 9

Peace Sells... but Who's Buying?

Wake Up Dead - 7
The Conjuring - 7
Peace Sells - 9
Devils Island - 9
Good Mourning / Black Friday - 7
Bad Omen - 8
I Ain't Superstitious - 6
My Last Words - 8

So Far, So Good... So What!

Into The Lungs Of Hell - 6
Set The World Afire - 7
Anarchy In The U.K. - 6
Mary Jane - 9
502 - 6
In My Darkest Hour - 13
Liar - 8
Hook In Mouth - 9

Rust in Peace

Holy Wars... The Punishment Due - 11
Hangar 18 - 9
Take No Prisoners - 9
Five Magics - 8
Poison Was The Cure - 7
Lucretia - 8
Tornado Of Souls - 12
Dawn Patrol - 7
Rust In Peace... Polaris - 9

Countdown to Extinction

Skin O' My Teeth - 8
Symphony Of Destruction - 7
Architecture Of Aggression - 7
Foreclosure Of A Dream - 6
Sweating Bullets - 9
This Was My Life - 9
Countdown To Extinction - 7
High Speed Dirt - 6
Psychotron - 7
Captive Honour - 8
Ashes In Your Mouth - 8

Youthanasia

Reckoning Day - 7
Train Of Consequences - 6
Addicted To Chaos - 7
A Tout Le Monde - 5
Elysian Fields - 6
The Killing Road - 6
Blood Of Heroes - 8
Family Tree - 7
Youthanasia - 9
I Thought I Knew It All - 9
Black Curtains - 6
Victory - 7

Cryptic Writings

Trust - 6
Almost Honest - 6
Use The Man - 7
Mastermind - 5
The Disintegrators - 7
I'll Get Even - 4
Sin - 3
A Secret Place - 10
Have Cool, Will Travel - 5
She-Wolf - 5
Vortex - 5
FFF - 5

Risk

Insomnia - 5
Prince Of Darkness - 7
Crush 'Em - 7
Breadline - 6
The Doctor Is Calling - 7
I'll Be There - 8
Wanderlust - 2
Ecstasy - 4
Seven - 5
Time: The Beginning - 7
Time: The End - 1

The World Needs a Hero

Disconnect - 6
The World Needs A Hero - 4
Moto Psycho - 5
1000 Times Goodbye - 9
Burning Bridges - 7
Promises - 9
Recipe For Hate... Warhorse - 6
Losing My Senses - 7
Dread And The Fugitive Mind - 8
Silent Scorn - 9
Return To Hangar -6
When - 4

The System Has Failed

Blackmail The Universe - 9
Die Dead Enough - 6
Kick The Chair - 5
The Scorpion - 9
Tears In A Vial - 8
Back In A Day - 8
Something That I'm Not - 7
Truth Be Told - 7
Of Mice And Men - 4
Shadow Of Deth - 4
My Kingdom - 2

United Abominations

Sleepwalker - 7
Washington Is Next! - 7
Never Walk Alone... A Call To Arms - 6
United Abominations - 5
Gears Of War - 8
Blessed Are The Dead - 5
Pray For Blood - 4
Amerikhastan - 4
You're Dead - 6
Burnt Ice - 6

Endgame

Dialectic Chaos - 8
This Day We Fight! - 9
44 Minutes - 9
1,320' - 7
Bite The Hand - 6
Bodies - 6
Endgame - 7
The Hardest Part Of Letting Go... - 8
Head Crusher - 7
How The Story Ends - 7
The Right To Go Insane - 7

TH1RT3EN

Sudden Death - 7
Public Enemy No. 1 - 7
Whose Life (Is It Anyways?) - 9
We the People - 8
Guns, Drugs & Money - 5
Never Dead - 8
New World Order - 7
Fast Lane - 7
Black Swan - 8
Wrecker - 7
Millennium of the Blind - 9
Deadly Nightshade - 7
13 - 8

Hidden Treasures

No More Mr. Nice Guy - 7
Breakpoint - 7
Go To Hell - 8
Angry Again - 9
99 Ways To Die - 6
Paranoid - 7
Diadems - 6
Problems - 5

non-album

Kill The King - 8
Duke Nukem Theme - 5
Crown Of Worms - 5
Coming Home -7
Never Say Die - 5
Out On The Tiles - 6
One Thing - 7
Strange Ways - 6

Pozdrawiam ;]
EDIT: Teraz już wszystko z ocenami git

Fajnie, dzięki
Coraz więcej nas przybywa.

Ale chyba oceniamy według starych zasad, nie? Jeśli tak, to ten punkt nie jest przestrzegany:

b) oceniamy utwory w obrębie całej skali, czyli musimy użyć tych najwyższych, jak i najniższych not (to jest niezbędne przy wyłanianiu średniej). Natomiast każdy już sobie wyznaczy, jakich ocen będzie najwiecej, a jakich najmniej. Nie ma zobowiązań, by w obrębie jakiejkolwiek płyty dać koniecznie najwyższą i najniższą notę;

Uprzejmie donoszę, że np. obywatel "kosciej7" żadnej "pały" nie wystawił.

_________________
www.believer.dbv.pl - moja strona o jednym z najlepszych bandów grających progresywny/techniczny thrash
www.crossroads-of-metal.blogspot.com

Warto też wspomnieć, że oceniamy w skali "megadethowej", czyli tolerancja ocen w jakiś sposób spada, że tak to ujmę.

Ten system w ogóle uważam za wujowy. Byłoby sprawiedliwiej gdyby każdy podawał "swój" ranking od najlepszej do najgorszej piosenki i według tego liczyć punkty, a jak każdy może dawać nieograniczoną liczbę 10-ek, to tak na dobrą sprawę mija się to wszystko z celem.